Author guest post from Helene Harrison.
Henry VIII’s ‘Great Matter’ of the 1520s and 1530s was his quest for a male heir to succeed him on the throne. The focus is so much on Henry VIII and the machinations of men like Thomas Wolsey and Thomas Cromwell, as well as Anne Boleyn. It was largely women, however, who were most adversely affected by the events of this time.
1) Katherine of Aragon
Katherine of Aragon was Henry VIII’s first wife, the one he wanted to annul his marriage to in the late 1520s. She was the mother of the king’s eldest daughter, Princess Mary (later Mary I), and had suffered the losses of multiple children through miscarriages, stillbirths, and even the loss of an infant son, Henry, Duke of Cornwall, in 1511. Katherine had previously been married to Henry VIII’s elder brother, Arthur, Prince of Wales, for six months until he died in April 1502. In June 1509 Henry married his brother’s widow, almost his first act on becoming king that year. By the mid-1520s with only a single surviving daughter and Katherine having last been pregnant in 1518 and past the age of childbearing, Henry came to believe that his marriage was invalid, and God had proven it by failing to give him male children. The king based his assertion on a passage in the Bible, which said that ‘and if a man shall take his brother’s wife, it is an unclean thing: he hath uncovered his brother’s nakedness; they shall be childless’ (Leviticus 20:21). Henry took childless to mean without sons, so he believed Katherine needed to go.

2) Elizabeth ‘Bessie’ Blount
Bessie Blount is the first of Henry VIII’s mistresses in his reign that we can be sure of. But it is unclear how long their affair lasted, when it started, and when it finished, though it likely ended when Bessie fell pregnant towards the end of 1518. This was the king’s child. Henry and Bessie’s son, Henry Fitzroy, was born in June 1519, given the name ‘Fitzroy’ meaning ‘son of the king’. While Bessie was becoming pregnant, Katherine of Aragon was also pregnant, for the final time. Bessie would succeed where Katherine had failed. Henry VIII would ensure that everyone knew that he could have a son, and that his lack of sons was not his fault – he very publicly created Henry Fitzroy Duke of Richmond and Somerset and Earl of Nottingham in 1525 when he was six years old. Bessie would be married off after Fitzroy’s birth, to Gilbert Tailboys, and after his death in 1530, she married again, to Edward Clinton, but she does not seem to return to court and is largely absent from records.
3) Mary Boleyn
Mary Boleyn is the second of Henry VIII’s mistresses that we can be sure of. This is because of a comment that Henry VIII made when confronted with a rumour that he had slept with Anne Boleyn’s sister and her mother, and he replied, ‘never with the mother’, thus not denying that he slept with her sister, Mary. The exact timing of Mary’s affair with the king is unclear and its duration is also unknown. Mary married William Carey in 1520 and they had two children – Catherine and Henry. It is possible, but not proven, that one or both children are actually the children of Henry VIII. We will never be able to prove this, however. When Henry VIII was looking to marry Mary’s sister, Anne, he applied for a dispensation to allow him to marry a woman to whom he was related within the first degree of affinity, which included a sexual relationship with her immediate relations. William Carey died of the sweating sickness in 1528 and in 1534 Mary remarried in secret, to William Stafford, who was serving in Calais. Mary was banished from court for not getting permission from her parents and sister, who was queen at this time, for her marriage. As far as we’re aware, Mary never returned to court and she died in 1543.

4) Anne Boleyn
Anne Boleyn, along with Katherine of Aragon, is the woman probably most closely associated with the ‘Great Matter’ as the woman that Henry VIII changed the face of England to marry. She had spent her formative years in the Low Countries and France, making her stand out when she returned to England in 1522. She had been romantically linked to both Henry Percy, heir to the Earl of Northumberland, and Thomas Wyatt, the poet. She soon caught the king’s attention and there is a surviving set of seventeen love letters in the Vatican, written by Henry VIII to Anne Boleyn, which is a unique set of letters, but we’re missing Anne’s responses, sadly. Anne was created Marquess of Pembroke in her own right in September 1532 then married Henry VIII in January 1533, though there is a suggestion they also married earlier in November 1532. Uniquely, Anne Boleyn was crown in June 1533 with St Edward’s crown, which is usually only used to crown the reigning monarch, not a consort. The future Elizabeth I was born that September, but Anne then suffered at least two miscarriages or stillbirths before she was arrested in May 1536, accused of adultery, incest, and treason, alongside five men including her own brother. She was executed on 19 May 1536, 2 days after her marriage was annulled.
5) Princess Mary Tudor, later Mary I
Princess Mary was the only surviving child of Henry VIII and Katherine of Aragon, born in February 1516. Mary had been betrothed to both the French dauphin, and the Holy Roman Emperor, Charles V, but neither betrothal resulted in a marriage. The suggestion had even been made that Mary should marry her illegitimate half-brother, Henry Fitzroy, though it isn’t sure how serious this suggestion was. When Mary was eleven years old, her father started the case to annul his marriage to Mary’s mother, Katherine. Mary would stand solidly by her mother in the case, though the pair would be separated in 1531, and they wouldn’t see each other again. In 1533 Henry had his marriage to Katherine declared null and void, and Mary was illegitimate, and in 1534 the Act of Succession declared that Mary was no longer the heir to the throne. Katherine of Aragon died in January 1536, and Anne Boleyn was executed in 1536. Mary hoped at this point, with Anne dead, that her father would reinstate her to the succession and allow her back to court. Henry VIII pressured Mary to accept the invalidity of her parents’ marriage, which she did in 1536, but never forgave herself. She was allowed back to court and seems to have had a positive relationship with Henry’s new wife, Jane Seymour.

6) Jane Seymour
Jane Seymour had been at court since at least the late 1520s, serving first Katherine of Aragon and then Anne Boleyn. She doesn’t seem to have elicited much attention prior to 1536 in court records. The first reference to her in relation to Henry VIII comes in February 1536 when the Imperial ambassador, Eustace Chapuys, mentioned that the king had been giving her presents and showing her attention. When Henry sent Jane a letter and purse of money, Jane kissed the letter and returned both, asking the messenger to tell the king that she had no greater thing in the world than her honour. Jane’s brother, Edward Seymour, was given rooms close to the king’s, where Henry VIII could court Jane while she was chaperoned by her family, to keep her reputation intact. Henry VIII became betrothed to Jane Seymour the day after Anne Boleyn’s execution, and they married ten days after that, on 30 May 1536. Jane didn’t immediately fall pregnant, but by the beginning of 1537 she was with child. She gave birth to the future Edward VI in October 1537 but died twelve days after her son’s birth. Henry VIII appears to have gone into mourning for Jane as he didn’t for any of his other wives. She succeeded and gave Henry VIII the son he had been looking for, for twenty-eight years.
You can purchase ‘Henry VIII’s Quest for an Heir: The King’s Great Matter’.
All of my books are on my author page on the Pen and Sword website.

